Tell us who deserves to be on the list.
The bar is high and every listed seller has to pass all of it, so give us enough to check: what you have seen them do, over how long, and why it stands out.
The bar
A nomination is only listed once every one of these holds. There is no partial credit:
- Prices at or below market. No gouging.
- Sells genuine product only: authentic sealed product and/or slabs from a recognized grader (PSA, CGC, BGS/Beckett, SGC, TAG). No fake or pop-up-grader slabs.
- No shill bidding.
- Calm, honest presentation. No false hype or pressure tactics.
- Accurate descriptions. Grade and condition shown clearly on screen.
- Buyer protection: honors refunds and returns on misdescribed items.
- Delivers as promised: ships what was won and honors high-value wins.
- Consistent identity across platforms.
- No substantiated complaints.
- At least two weeks of consistent observation confirming all of the above.
You stay anonymous. There is no name or email field on this form. We do not ask for or store your identity as the nominator.
Most nominations do not make it on. That is by design. A seller only gets listed once we have watched them ourselves for at least two weeks and confirmed every criterion holds up, so expect this to take a while either way.
Looking for the list itself? See the trusted-seller directory. Have a complaint instead? That is a different form: file a report.