A short list, on purpose.
This is the opposite of the record: a directory of sellers who were checked against a strict, all-or-nothing bar and passed every part of it. Most nominations do not make it on, and that is what makes the ones that do worth something.
What it takes to be listed
A seller is listed only once every one of these holds. There is no partial credit and no exception:
- Prices at or below market. No gouging.
- Sells genuine product only: authentic sealed product and/or slabs from a recognized grader (PSA, CGC, BGS/Beckett, SGC, TAG). No fake or pop-up-grader slabs.
- No shill bidding.
- Calm, honest presentation. No false hype or pressure tactics.
- Accurate descriptions. Grade and condition shown clearly on screen.
- Buyer protection: honors refunds and returns on misdescribed items.
- Delivers as promised: ships what was won and honors high-value wins.
- Consistent identity across platforms.
- No substantiated complaints.
- At least two weeks of consistent observation confirming all of the above.
Nobody is listed yet.
The bar above is strict on purpose, and it takes at least two weeks of watching a seller before anyone can be listed. Know a seller who consistently clears all of it?
Nominate a seller